Weapon Proficienciy and Weapon Kata question

Mysticism, spies, cybernetic implants, & cool vehicles. Discuss these two great classics here.

Moderators: Immortals, Supreme Beings, Old Ones

User avatar
Glistam
Megaversal® Ambassador
Posts: 3631
Joined: Tue Apr 05, 2005 2:09 pm
Comment: The silent thief of Rozrehxeson.
Location: Connecticut
Contact:

Weapon Proficienciy and Weapon Kata question

Unread post by Glistam »

Some martial art forms in the book provide W.P. skills as part of their training, but don't list that W.P. in the weapon kata section. Does this mean that even though the martial art training included the W.P., it wasn't advanced enough to actually combine with the martial art form, and thus can't be used with it? Or should it be assumed that if a martial art form teaches a W.P., it also provides the associated weapon kata?
Zerebus: "I like MDC. MDC is a hundred times better than SDC."

kiralon: "...the best way to kill an old one is to crash a moon into it."

Image

Temporal Wizard O.C.C. update 0.8 | Rifts random encounters
New Fire magic | New Temporal magic
Grim Gulf, the Nightlands version of Century Station

Let Chaos Magic flow in your campaigns.
User avatar
eliakon
Palladin
Posts: 9093
Joined: Sat Jul 14, 2007 9:40 pm
Comment: Palladium Books Canon is set solely by Kevin Siembieda, either in person, or by his approval of published material.
Contact:

Re: Weapon Proficienciy and Weapon Kata question

Unread post by eliakon »

Mileage may vary, but for me, if a martial art form includes a WP, then you automatically get the Kata for that weapon. Since yah it makes it hard to train to use a weapon....if you cant use the weapon :P
The rules are not a bludgeon with which to hammer a character into a game. They are a guide to how a group of friends can get together to weave a collective story that entertains everyone involved. We forget that at our peril.

Edmund Burke wrote:The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing."
User avatar
Alrik Vas
Knight
Posts: 4810
Joined: Tue Mar 19, 2013 8:20 pm
Comment: Don't waste your time gloating over a wounded enemy. Pull the damn trigger.
Location: Right behind you.

Re: Weapon Proficienciy and Weapon Kata question

Unread post by Alrik Vas »

I thought a weapon kata just taught the WP for the purposes of using that specific form, whereas if you had the WP, you could use it no matter what form you were using?
Mark Hall wrote:Y'all seem to assume that Palladium books are written with the same exacting precision with which they are analyzed. I think that is... ambitious.

Talk from the Edge: Operation Dead Lift, Operation Reload, Operation Human Devil, Operation Handshake, Operation Windfall 1, Operation Windfall 2, Operation Sniper Wolf, Operation Natural 20
User avatar
Tor
Palladin
Posts: 6975
Joined: Thu Aug 09, 2012 2:37 pm
Comment: If you have something to say, back it up with thoughts and reasons. Simply posting to agree or disagree tends to be a waste.
Location: Pyramid

Re: Weapon Proficienciy and Weapon Kata question

Unread post by Tor »

eliakon wrote:Mileage may vary, but for me, if a martial art form includes a WP, then you automatically get the Kata for that weapon. Since yah it makes it hard to train to use a weapon....if you cant use the weapon :P

This is incorrect. You only get the Kata if it says you get the Kata. This is very clear in arts like Zanji which only give you a kata in a single weapon while giving you several other WPs without katas.

This clearly means it is only PP+WP for strike/parry. Not sure on the issue of attacks.

Katas are superior to WP due to the stacking. WP can be used with anything but don't stack.

There's also subleties like being able to use a weapon for more than just striking. Certain Atemi and martial arts techniques have wording vague enough that they could be done with WP, such as Vital Points.
"1st edition? 2nd edition? It doesnt matter! Let's just talk" -Forums of the Megaverse
User avatar
Svartalf
Champion
Posts: 2817
Joined: Fri Jun 11, 2004 1:39 pm
Comment: Beware of the Friar Tuck type putting on the French Maid outfit!
Location: Paris, France
Contact:

Re: Weapon Proficienciy and Weapon Kata question

Unread post by Svartalf »

Nope, to enjoy the bonuses of your form with a weapon, you need to have weapon kata, if you don't, you just have the bonuses of proficiency (if you are proficient).
If you have both weapon kata and proficiency, the bonuses stack.

You'll notice, for instance that Ninjutsu teaches a bevy of exotic weapons, but only two kata. One of the weapons offered for kata, the ninja sword, is not among the proficiencies, so you get only nijnutsu's bonuses to hit, parry etc with it (unless you use a secondary skill slot to get the proficiency).
Image
Svartalf - Flamboyantly Fresh Franco of Freedom Freakin' Fries : Shadyslug
Embrace the Darkness, it needs a hug - Cherico
PC stands for "patronizing cretin" G'mo
I name you honorary American Subjugator & Ratbastard
User avatar
Nightmask
Palladin
Posts: 9268
Joined: Sat Apr 16, 2011 7:39 am

Re: Weapon Proficienciy and Weapon Kata question

Unread post by Nightmask »

Svartalf wrote:Nope, to enjoy the bonuses of your form with a weapon, you need to have weapon kata, if you don't, you just have the bonuses of proficiency (if you are proficient).
If you have both weapon kata and proficiency, the bonuses stack.

You'll notice, for instance that Ninjutsu teaches a bevy of exotic weapons, but only two kata. One of the weapons offered for kata, the ninja sword, is not among the proficiencies, so you get only nijnutsu's bonuses to hit, parry etc with it (unless you use a secondary skill slot to get the proficiency).


I believe that's more because if you acquire a Weapon Kata in something you automatically gain Weapon Proficiency in it (which certainly makes sense, you can hardly master use of a weapon for a style if you haven't even learned how to use the weapon in general). So selecting 'Weapon Kata-Ninja Sword' includes 'Weapon Proficiency-Ninja Sword', you just don't get it as an automatic selection as a WP without the kata as well.
Fair warning: I consider being called a munchkin a highly offensive slur and do report people when they err in doing so.

'Reality is very disappointing.' - Jonathan Switcher from Mannequin

It's 'canon', not 'cannon'. A cannon is a big gun like on pirate ships, canon is what you mean when referring to something as being contained within one of the books such as how many dice to roll for a stat.
User avatar
Svartalf
Champion
Posts: 2817
Joined: Fri Jun 11, 2004 1:39 pm
Comment: Beware of the Friar Tuck type putting on the French Maid outfit!
Location: Paris, France
Contact:

Re: Weapon Proficienciy and Weapon Kata question

Unread post by Svartalf »

Sorry but no cigar, if you check the description of ninjutsu in N&SS, you'll notice that among the weapons offered for kata are the knife and kusarigama, which are also noted among the taught WP skills... either my theory is correct or a huge mistake passed through proof reading twice (original edition, AND revision). Plus, nowhere in any section pertaining to weapon kata is it said or implied that the corresponding WP (and its bonuses) was included. Kobujutsu is the ability to merge weapon use with one's martial arts form to benefit from the form's bonuses.
Image
Svartalf - Flamboyantly Fresh Franco of Freedom Freakin' Fries : Shadyslug
Embrace the Darkness, it needs a hug - Cherico
PC stands for "patronizing cretin" G'mo
I name you honorary American Subjugator & Ratbastard
User avatar
Tor
Palladin
Posts: 6975
Joined: Thu Aug 09, 2012 2:37 pm
Comment: If you have something to say, back it up with thoughts and reasons. Simply posting to agree or disagree tends to be a waste.
Location: Pyramid

Re: Weapon Proficienciy and Weapon Kata question

Unread post by Tor »

Svart you automatically get the WP if you get the kata, pg123's description explicitly states that "Taking this kata automatically gives the character full WP with the weapon named".

The WP and kata selections of Ninjutsu don't contradict this in any way. In this case it just means you get more bang for your buck if you select Ninja Sword, since then you get a WP you don't have automatically (WP sword, albeit limited to a specific kind), whereas in the case of the other katas, you are merely getting the added kata abilities to existing WPs.

I'm not seeing how the overlap (or lack thereof) would be a mistake. This would be true if you were given a fixed WP kata that duplicated a WP skill, but there's no conflict if you can only choose some (in this case 2) of several katas and thus none are fixed.
"1st edition? 2nd edition? It doesnt matter! Let's just talk" -Forums of the Megaverse
User avatar
Svartalf
Champion
Posts: 2817
Joined: Fri Jun 11, 2004 1:39 pm
Comment: Beware of the Friar Tuck type putting on the French Maid outfit!
Location: Paris, France
Contact:

Re: Weapon Proficienciy and Weapon Kata question

Unread post by Svartalf »

Damn, see what I get for not paying proper attention, you and Nightmask are correct of course.
Image
Svartalf - Flamboyantly Fresh Franco of Freedom Freakin' Fries : Shadyslug
Embrace the Darkness, it needs a hug - Cherico
PC stands for "patronizing cretin" G'mo
I name you honorary American Subjugator & Ratbastard
tsh77769
Dungeon Crawler
Posts: 211
Joined: Fri Sep 20, 2002 1:01 am

Re: Weapon Proficienciy and Weapon Kata question

Unread post by tsh77769 »

So if I understand correctly...

All Kata include the WP but WP does not include the kata.

The benefit of the kata is that you can use the WP bonuses and the forms bonuses together.

I can use a weapon I have a WP for while I am using a form, but I can not combine the forms bonuses with the WP bonuses.

tsh77769
User avatar
drewkitty ~..~
Monk
Posts: 17737
Joined: Sat Sep 30, 2000 1:01 am
Location: Eastvale, calif
Contact:

Re: Weapon Proficienciy and Weapon Kata question

Unread post by drewkitty ~..~ »

The WP's that are not a part of a WK do not get the MAF bonuses.
May you be blessed with the ability to change course when you are off the mark.
Each question should be give the canon answer 1st, then you can proclaim your house rules.
Reading and writing (literacy) is how people on BBS interact.
User avatar
Tor
Palladin
Posts: 6975
Joined: Thu Aug 09, 2012 2:37 pm
Comment: If you have something to say, back it up with thoughts and reasons. Simply posting to agree or disagree tends to be a waste.
Location: Pyramid

Re: Weapon Proficienciy and Weapon Kata question

Unread post by Tor »

tsh77769 wrote:The benefit of the kata is that you can use the WP bonuses and the forms bonuses together.

Another benefit is that you can use the weapons with the techniques.

Bonuses are what we mainly focus on, but 'techniques' covers any special moves the form provides, including associated Atemi skills not limited to HtH techniques.

For example, say your super-hero friend made of Plasma was deafened by an enemy using Atemi.

You have a Healing Atemi move, but if you did it with your body to help him, the contact would burn your limbs off.

Luckily you have a Bo Staff Weapon Kata, so you are able to hit him with a 10ft pole and cure him of his deafness, and it only burns up a length of wood instead of your finger.

Something else worth noting: automatic parry is something provided by HtH forms.

This means that unless you have a WP Kata, parrying with a mere WP skill will cost you an attack. Automatic parry could only be used with weapons if you have the kata.

Far as I know, sans Kata, the only thing you use from your HtH form is attacks per melee. Plus obvious passive stuff like SDC bonuses or savings throws.
"1st edition? 2nd edition? It doesnt matter! Let's just talk" -Forums of the Megaverse
User avatar
fbdaury
Dungeon Crawler
Posts: 207
Joined: Sat Jan 29, 2005 10:43 pm

Re: Weapon Proficienciy and Weapon Kata question

Unread post by fbdaury »

In the specific example of the Ninja sword from Ninjitsu and the Kobu-Jutsu example from page 123 of the N&SS book, the downside to getting the WP for Ninja Sword as part of a Weapon Kata for that form is that you are only able to use the Ninja Sword with Ninjitsu- as pointed out in the provided example of WK Spear with Isshin-Ryu and how it cannot be used outside Isshin-Ryu combat.
User avatar
Nightmask
Palladin
Posts: 9268
Joined: Sat Apr 16, 2011 7:39 am

Re: Weapon Proficienciy and Weapon Kata question

Unread post by Nightmask »

fbdaury wrote:In the specific example of the Ninja sword from Ninjitsu and the Kobu-Jutsu example from page 123 of the N&SS book, the downside to getting the WP for Ninja Sword as part of a Weapon Kata for that form is that you are only able to use the Ninja Sword with Ninjitsu- as pointed out in the provided example of WK Spear with Isshin-Ryu and how it cannot be used outside Isshin-Ryu combat.


You can use the spear outside of the Isshin-Ryu style, you just can't add the bonuses from Isshin-Ryu style to combat with the spear when not using that style at the time only the bonuses from WP Spear.
Fair warning: I consider being called a munchkin a highly offensive slur and do report people when they err in doing so.

'Reality is very disappointing.' - Jonathan Switcher from Mannequin

It's 'canon', not 'cannon'. A cannon is a big gun like on pirate ships, canon is what you mean when referring to something as being contained within one of the books such as how many dice to roll for a stat.
User avatar
fbdaury
Dungeon Crawler
Posts: 207
Joined: Sat Jan 29, 2005 10:43 pm

Re: Weapon Proficienciy and Weapon Kata question

Unread post by fbdaury »

From N&SS page 123, under the description for Kobu-Jutsu: "For example, a character with Isshin-Ryu could take a Spear Weapon Kata. That would allow the use of a spear while fighting with the usual Isshin-Ryu moves and bonuses. But he can only use the spear with Isshin-Ryu combat."

Emphasis on the bold section.
User avatar
Nightmask
Palladin
Posts: 9268
Joined: Sat Apr 16, 2011 7:39 am

Re: Weapon Proficienciy and Weapon Kata question

Unread post by Nightmask »

fbdaury wrote:From N&SS page 123, under the description for Kobu-Jutsu: "For example, a character with Isshin-Ryu could take a Spear Weapon Kata. That would allow the use of a spear while fighting with the usual Isshin-Ryu moves and bonuses. But he can only use the spear with Isshin-Ryu combat."

Emphasis on the bold section.


You're misreading that, it means he can't use the Spear Weapon Kata he learned for Isshin-Ryu outside Isshin-Ryu not that he can't use a spear at all unless it's while using Isshin-Ryu. Anyone can use any weapon even if they don't have a weapon proficiency for it but they can't gain the bonuses of a particular martial art using a weapon unless they have that particular weapon kata with that particular martial art. So since taking a weapon kata automatically gives you the weapon proficiency as well the character always has the Spear weapon proficiency's bonuses when using a spear but can only add into that the bonuses from Isshin-Ryu while using the Isshin-Ryu style.
Fair warning: I consider being called a munchkin a highly offensive slur and do report people when they err in doing so.

'Reality is very disappointing.' - Jonathan Switcher from Mannequin

It's 'canon', not 'cannon'. A cannon is a big gun like on pirate ships, canon is what you mean when referring to something as being contained within one of the books such as how many dice to roll for a stat.
User avatar
eliakon
Palladin
Posts: 9093
Joined: Sat Jul 14, 2007 9:40 pm
Comment: Palladium Books Canon is set solely by Kevin Siembieda, either in person, or by his approval of published material.
Contact:

Re: Weapon Proficienciy and Weapon Kata question

Unread post by eliakon »

Nightmask wrote:
fbdaury wrote:From N&SS page 123, under the description for Kobu-Jutsu: "For example, a character with Isshin-Ryu could take a Spear Weapon Kata. That would allow the use of a spear while fighting with the usual Isshin-Ryu moves and bonuses. But he can only use the spear with Isshin-Ryu combat."

Emphasis on the bold section.


You're misreading that, it means he can't use the Spear Weapon Kata he learned for Isshin-Ryu outside Isshin-Ryu not that he can't use a spear at all unless it's while using Isshin-Ryu. Anyone can use any weapon even if they don't have a weapon proficiency for it but they can't gain the bonuses of a particular martial art using a weapon unless they have that particular weapon kata with that particular martial art. So since taking a weapon kata automatically gives you the weapon proficiency as well the character always has the Spear weapon proficiency's bonuses when using a spear but can only add into that the bonuses from Isshin-Ryu while using the Isshin-Ryu style.

Correct, you can use the WP at will.
However, if you want to use the WK (Weapon Kata) in two martial arts, you need to learn it twice, once for both martial arts.
Its sort of like getting two skills
You get a WP and a WK. The WK supersedes the WP, but can only be used in the Martial Art it was learned in.
The rules are not a bludgeon with which to hammer a character into a game. They are a guide to how a group of friends can get together to weave a collective story that entertains everyone involved. We forget that at our peril.

Edmund Burke wrote:The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing."
User avatar
Tor
Palladin
Posts: 6975
Joined: Thu Aug 09, 2012 2:37 pm
Comment: If you have something to say, back it up with thoughts and reasons. Simply posting to agree or disagree tends to be a waste.
Location: Pyramid

Re: Weapon Proficienciy and Weapon Kata question

Unread post by Tor »

The WP gained from a WP kata can be used in any hand-to-hand just not combined with its bonuses.

So there's no downside to getting Ninja Sword as kata instead of WP.
"1st edition? 2nd edition? It doesnt matter! Let's just talk" -Forums of the Megaverse
Post Reply

Return to “Ninjas & Superspies™ & Mystic China™”